Criminal Justice

NOPD ends controversial practice of releasing criminal records of homicide victims

Police Superintendent Ronal Serpas announced today he will no longer release the arrest records of homicide victims, reversing a controversial and unevenly applied practice that had come under intense criticism in recent days.

The about-face comes a week after Serpas took more than a day to release the arrest record of a Good Samaritan homicide victim in Algiers, compared to a few hours for most other homicide victims.

That release last week came shortly after The Lens reported that the department wasn’t following its usual practice in releasing the victim’s record. Other news outlets followed suit. A search of a newspaper database shows more than 25 newspapers, as well as the Huffington Post website, ran an Associated Press story over the weekend examining the controversial policy.

Since then, talk show hosts, columnists and on-air TV editorialists have ripped the policy. And state Sen. J.P. Morrell, D-New Orleans, drafted a bill to prevent the police from releasing such information.

The practice was taking heat even before a would-be carjacker in Algiers killed Harry “Mike” Ainsworth, who turned out to have a record stretching back years for drug possession.

Two City Council members criticized Serpas when he appeared before the council’s Criminal Justice Committee on Jan. 18.

Serpas told the committee that most homicides in the city were “black males killing black males,” and said releasing their arrest records helps the community have an informed discussion about homicides. Ainsworth was white.

Activist group Safe Streets / Strong Communities this week began a petition calling for the practice to stop, and it had gathered 184 signatures before organizers closed today after the policy change. Executive director of Safe Streets / Strong Communities Yvette Thierry said the group is still discussing its reaction to the news.

Morrell said Serpas spent more time crafting the press release about Ainsworth’s arrest record than the arrest records of other homicide victims.

“The press release for Mr. Ainsworth rehabilitated him,” Morrell said. “It said he had worked to be part of the community in the 8th District, but that same level of care did not go into the press releases on the other victims whose grieving families had to suffer the embarrassment of having their loved ones’ arrest records paraded publicly.”

Morrell said he thought community pressure had a role in forcing Serpas to change his mind.

“I think it was really a perfect storm of issues coming together,” Morrell said. “I know you can’t talk about yourselves, but The Lens’ pressure to release Mr. Ainsworth’s arrest record along with the pressure from community groups on this practice, coupled with my legislation, I think it really gave the police chief no option. He realized that this was not an issue that was going to go away.”

Serpas announced the decision in a press release this afternoon and was unavailable for further comment. He now plans to release monthly aggregate statistics on the number of homicide victims with a history of felony arrests, but without naming the victims.

“I believe it is necessary to share with the community the obvious and direct link between criminal behavior and the horrible acts of murder in our city,” Serpas said in his news release. “I have always said, however, that there are very good arguments to share and not share this public information.

“After consulting privately with local clergy leaders over the last weeks, starting today, our press releases will no longer include the individual public arrest record of a homicide victim.”

Help us report this story     Report an error    
The Lens' donors and partners may be mentioned or have a stake in the stories we cover.
  • Matt Davis

    This came too late to make the story, but I just spoke with Alison McCrary, one of the advocates behind the petition to stop the practice. She’s not pleased about the chief’s decision to continue releasing victim information on a monthly basis.

    “While I’m grateful that Chief Serpas is listening to the people and the community, the monthly release of statistical data on homicide victims, I don’t think is a good use of police resources, and it doesn’t affect or reduce the crime rate,” McCrary said. “I hope this is a small step to start building some trust and confidence in the police department since Chief Serpas’s new leadership, but we need to look at the root cause of crime, and if we’re spending police dollars doing statistical analysis on data related to victims, those same resources can be spent on education and training opportunities, to address the root causes of the problem.”

  • Thomas Johnson

    I become more concerned with the questionable actions of this city’s politicians every passing day – and with the way the city continues to simply put up with it.

    This administration has brought this department of justice circus to town, single-handedly run off 20% of the police force, presided over the biggest increase in crime in recent decades……and they sit around making lazy, half a** excuses, and refuse to address concerns of the public with anything other than political circular talk.

    I want to know why WE are continuing to fill these idiot’s pockets?

    A very small handful of well connected people running this city into the ground are working very hard at ensuring everyone gets their publicly funded pensions before this city collapses for good.

  • Michael

    Alison, if you actually looked at the NOPD homicide background stats for 2012 to date, you’d see the the victims are 60% likely to have been felons and 90% likely to be jobless. These stats are almost identical to those for the killers.

  • keep my real

    You should see Serpas’ record. including violating city ordinance and suspended for having sex with prostitutes.

  • Gary

    Serpas was corrupt in another state, so we now import crooks like we don’t have enough to choose from here ?

  • Andrea Jean

    I am glad this is stopping, thanks to the lens. It’s sad that some of the commenters jumped to conclusions instead of reading the entire article.

    NOPD was basically saying “See? Not our fault, the guy got arrested 10 years ago for crack, he deserved it!” That’s pretty hurtful and Anti-American. Everyone deserves a second chance. Hell, some of the people that I have had the privilege of serving in the military with have records.

  • Pingback: Lens co-founder wins award for report on NOPD victim policy | : Investigative Journalism New Orleans()