Squandered Heritage Vintage

Gustav Revisted or Rosedale Baptist Church vs The City of New Orleans

Metairie Orleans

This past Monday and Tuesday the case of The Rosedale Baptist Church vs C. Ray Nagin was heard in federal court in front of the Honorable Judge Martin Feldman.

The 6 person jury, oddly none of which reside in Orleans Parish heard 2 days of testimony about the post Gustav demolition of the Rosedale Baptist Church in New Orleans East. At the time the City was working overtime to demolish a number of structures post Gustav, it was revealed in Court that the funds for these demolitions were more readily available Post Gustav than they had been Post Katrina and Ed Blakely, former recovery Czar was coordinating efforts to ensure these demolitions would take place swiftly. The demolition contract, awarded to Metro Durr on this building was over 58,000.00. Clearly someone had an incentive to see this building demolished, a building which had been gutted the week before Gustav after a lengthly legal battle with the Insurance company.

The task at hand was to determine if the building was in fact in Imminent Danger of Collapse and if so who made that decision and how was that determination made.

In opening the Judge said that this was “a simple straightforward and important case because it involved the constitution” and the lawyer for the plantiffs, Henry Klein laid out a case which stated that the civil rights of the members of the Church were denied because they had not been offered due process. No notifications nor attempts to notify were made on the part of the City.

The city failed to fulfill it’s obligation to present a clear, complete and legible inspection report. Pages missing and incomplete forms as well as unsigned documents were presented.

After day 1 it was clear that the city had little ground to stand on and the best they could do was mitigate whatever damage had been done. One of the church members told me after Mondays court session the City called with an offer of $100,000.00, the Church refused and court was again in session today.

Franz Ziblich attorney for the City seemed to be suggesting that the demolition was a windfall for the plantiff’s and that they stood to gain by the unwanted City mandated demolition. In a grabbing at straws final argument Ziblich presented a confusing mathamatical equation which no one seemed to buy.

Jury was out for an hour..the verdict..The City of New Orleans violated the constitutional rights of the Church members and Rosedale Baptist Church was awarded $300,00.00 in damages.

Help us report this story     Report an error    
The Lens' donors and partners may be mentioned or have a stake in the stories we cover.
About Karen Gadbois

Karen Gadbois co-founded The Lens. She now covers New Orleans government issues and writes about land use for Squandered Heritage. For her work with television reporter Lee Zurik exposing widespread misuse of city recovery funds — which led to guilty pleas in federal court — Gadbois won some of the highest honors in journalism, including a Peabody Award, an Alfred I. duPont-Columbia Award and a gold medal from Investigative Reporters and Editors. She can be reached at (504) 606-6013.

  • Laureen

    Good reporting, Karen. I was glad I was able to attend the second day and watch the wheels of justice work for the parishoners of Rosedale and for the constitutional due process for all citizens of New Orleans. The City has been alerted that they can’t trample the civil rights of our citizens by depriving them of their property without proper due process. It was a fascinating day !

  • Georgia Bryant

    Great job, Karen! Obviously there were “vested interests” in the demolitions. Our erstwhile “recovery czar” seemed to be more interested in destruction than in rebuilding.

  • gordon

    Thanks Karen,
    Can we hold any person(s) accountable?This happens all to often,and is a waste of our valuable time and resources.My concern is that it continues.