Stifling science: State officials threaten medical conferees with hotel quarantine

caduceusWhen the annual conference of the American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene begins Sunday in New Orleans it will be missing some of the leading Ebola researchers and scientists.


They were disinvited by Gov. Bobby Jindal’s administration. Misinformed officials with the Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals sent a letter to conference participants stating that those who have returned in the past 21 days from the African countries where Ebola is centered  — Sierra Leone, Guinea and Liberia — should not travel to New Orleans to attend the conference.

Their pronouncement was condescending: “ … we see no utility in you traveling to New Orleans to simply be confined to your room.”

The state’s mandate clearly exceeds the most recent guidelines issued by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and belies the fact that Ebola is not transmitted by casual contact.

Such dismissive language does New Orleans and Louisiana no service. Indeed it disgraces New Orleans as a city that needs to sustain a reputation for intelligent and incisive medical research, if it is to keep the medical world returning for the conventions that are a key part of our economic life blood.

Being a port city has been a boon for New Orleans, one that carries a burden. With international commerce comes international exposure to diseases that know no borders.

But New Orleans also has a long and rich history of research and success in overcoming tropical  diseases that used to plague the city, among them malaria, cholera and yellow fever. Tulane University School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, which celebrated its centennial last year, was established in New Orleans because founders believed that tropical diseases are best studied in the environment in which they occur.

Now some of us who would ordinarily be responding to the African crisis — I had arranged to serve a stint with Medecins sans Frontieres (Doctors without borders, the international medical relief organization) — must scrap those plans because of the 21-day quarantine we would face upon return to Louisiana.

New Orleans had the opportunity to show once again that science and public health will overcome a tropical disease. Yet the state officials, without grounding their policy in science, are rejecting the contributions of individuals with Ebola expertise. We need these scientists. We should welcome them.

Lorelei Cropley, PhD, is a clinical associate professor of public health at Tulane.

Help us report this story     Report an error    
The Lens' donors and partners may be mentioned or have a stake in the stories we cover.
  • Rico

    Actions of states such as New Jersey, NY, Maine, and most recently, as mentioned in the above article, Louisiana are a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution. Nurse Hickox is on solid legal ground when she threatened to challenge her NJ “quarantine” and is now defying Maine’s threatened state action. The same would apply here for Louisiana and the ASTMH conference.

    Not being based on science, and going above and beyond CDC and federal recommendations, the state’s threatened action cannot be said to be “rationally related” to a legitimate state interest, the standard to pass constitutional muster.

    Louisiana’s position is unfortunate and coming from the same state that has no qualms approving with little regulation investments from chemical and oil and gas interests, boasting waterways among the most polluted in the nation (http://www.nola.com/business/index.ssf/2014/06/louisiana_waterways_among_most.html), and possessing one of the highest cancer mortality rate in the nation.

    Forget the facts when politics gets in the way…

  • nickelndime

    Louisiana is one of the biggest “at-risk” states in the nation, regularly exposing residents and illegal immigrants, who are here for any extended time, (tourists need not worry – they are exempt from local conditions) to carcinogens and pollution of all types. Why stop now? Come on down, up, east, west, from wherever. We welcome exposure to the Ebola virus because we have been told that it cannot be casually transmitted. We believe almost everything. Many Louisiana residents (#49) are at-risk in every classifiable way anyway – medically-financially-academically-socially-cognitively…- so let ’em come on down and let ’em out of their hotel rooms, 4gawdsake! If it doesn’t work out, contact the CDC or Nurse Hickox.

  • nickelndime

    21 days is not that long! – I think that the good “doctor” should give it a shot. Upon returning to this country, however, I would suggest a long trip home (to another state) – as least for a while until the rest of the country’s panic has subsided.