Citizen engagement got its own line in the 2011 budget brought before the City Council today by Mayor Mitch Landrieu.
Among the items funded within the $126 million proposed budget for the Mayor’s Office is $483,950 for the creation of an Office of Neighborhood and Citizen Engagement. If funded, the office would be the city’s first attempt at formalizing the city’s approach to public participation and, potentially, an answer to rules imposed by the master plan requiring a structured approach to citizen involvement.
As described in the budget presented by the administration, the mandate of the proposed office is “to provide a permanent mechanism for citizens to participate in local problem solving – from blight eradication to NORD.”
The mayor did not immediately respond to questions about how the new office will function, but advocates for citizen participation say the new office, in concept, is a good thing.
“Hopefully this will help make sure neighborhoods get served and people have input,” said Keith Twitchell, executive director of Committee for a Better New Orleans.
Twitchell’s nonprofit has been working on creating its own model for a system that would fill the master-plan requirement since 2003, long before the plan became law this year. Over the past few years, the organization has held dozens of community meetings, working with neighborhood groups and City Planning staff to fine-tune what the organization calls a “citizen participation plan.” Even so, Twitchell says the nonprofit was not consulted on the proposed office.
“But I don’t think it’s a threat to the CPP,” he said. “There are a lot of cities that have both an office of neighborhoods and a citizen participation program, whether people want it done that way here is still up for discussion. It’s not an either-or situation.”
Earlier this month, the effort faced a setback when Councilwoman Jackie Clarkson said no single plan being circulated will be adopted and she wants the commission to start over and hold a series of public meetings to gather input.
Update: Oct. 15 5:22 pm
Landrieu spokesman Ryan Berni has gotten back to our question about whether the new office will fulfill the obligations for a participation plan outlined in the Master Plan and the verdict is no. In Berni’s words: “The office addresses the recommendation of the Neighborhood Development Task Force for a dedicated Office of Neighborhoods and is separate from the obligation that the Master Plan creates.”
Seeing, and experiencing is believing. Those neighborhood meetings held by Mayor Landrieu were a long way from citizen participation. Just iced us down and went on his way. Now that the biggest and baddest damage is done, i.e Baton Rouge and LSU landgrabbing a done deal, we get to participate, maybe, in less community important matters? We are not stupid, and the largest of the damage is done. A second term is still very much in question. De facto meetings with no ability to change what city government gave to Baton Rouge is not going to ice anyone down. Not even the thought counts on this one, given the timing.
Until grassroots neighborhood association presidents are appointed to these panels and boards, government will NEVER understand the heartbeat of community concerns. Most CEOs, college presidents, and other upper management people don’t even attend neighborhood association meetings. It is not until local leaders want something (e.g., NORD Reform, etc.) that they are interested in the pulse of the community.
Worth repeating: Gloria DeCuir-Robert “Until grassroots neighborhood association presidents are appointed to these panels and boards, government will NEVER understand the heartbeat of community concerns. Most CEOs, college presidents, and other upper management people don