HDLC March 9 Results

Historic District Landmarks Commission
Meeting RESULTS
9:30 a.m., March 9, 2007
City Council Chambers, City Hall

RESULTS

Algiers Point
427 Atlantic Ave.: Request for the retention of work completed in deviation
from approved drawings. Chris Kenyon, owner; Nurhan Gokturk, applicant.
RESULT: Approved retention of inappropriately installed chain wall vents and
exposed plumbing to be mitigated with plantings; Approved retention of
inappropriately installed front façade windows with trim piece to be
installed and painted window color; Denied retention of roof overhang and
inappropriately installed 8 inch weatherboards

838-40 Belleville St. Demolition by Neglect, Preliminary Citation. RESULT:
Approved

823-25 Elmira St.: Request for the retention of an architectural grade brown
roof. Aaron Robinson, owner; William Sutherland, applicant. RESULT: Approved
because dark color of roof shingle

232 Homer St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING with redevelopment plans. Blaine S.
Kern, owner/applicant; Mathes Brierre, architect. RESULT: Approved

337 Morgan St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Warren Munster, owner/applicant.
RESULT: Approved

803 Slidell St.: Request for the retention of alterations to an existing
two-story building. Second floor addition added and roof line altered. Lisa
Guidry, owner/applicant. RESULT: Deferred indefinitely to ensure building
meets city building codes (work started without a building permit)

Bywater
4200-02 Burgundy St. Demolition by Neglect, Preliminary Citation. RESULT:
Approved

838 Congress St. Demolition by Neglect, Formal Citation RESULT: Approved

616 Gallier St.: Proposal for the installation of vinyl windows on all
elevations. Joseph & Frances Bernard, owner/applicants. RESULT: Deferred 30
days due to lack of appearance by applicant

1111-13 Louisa St.. Demolition by Neglect, Preliminary Citation RESULT:
Approved

709 Mazant St.: Demolition by Neglect, Preliminary Citation RESULT:
Approved

3029-31 St. Claude Ave.: Request for the retention of inappropriate windows
installed without a Certificate of Appropriateness. Richard Dufrene, Jr.
owner/applicant. RESULT: Denied retention of vinyl windows on the front
façade and street side of the house; Approved retention of the vinyl windows
on the non-street side of the house and those that the owner can prove were
aluminum pre-Katrina.

Central City
1212-14 Baronne St.: Removal of nomination as a landmark RESULT: Approved

1130 Baronne St.: Removal of nomination as a landmark. RESULT: Approved

1812-14 Carondelet St.: Removal of nomination as a landmark. RESULT:
Approved

1731-33 Clio St.: Removal of nomination as a landmark. RESULT: Approved

Faubourg Marigny
2519-21 Burgundy St.: Request for the retention of two exterior lights
installed without a Certificate of Appropriateness. Proposal for the
installation a minimally visible vinyl window at side elevation. Sylvia
Ballard Huete, owner. Carol Evans, applicant. RESULT: Approved installation
of vinyl window provided it is recessed and covered with a wood window
screen; Denied the retention of the two exterior lights

1928 Dauphine St.: Proposal for the DEMOLITION OF AN EXISTING BUILDING and
the construction of a single family 3-bay camelback shotgun. Victoria
Naegele, owner; Aaron Shepard, applicant; Katherine Harmon, architect.
RESULT: Approved

Faubourg St. John
2812 De Soto St.: Proposal for the construction of a rear addition onto an
existing two-story residence. Grant Ligon, owner applicant; Mathew Voelkel,
architect. RESULT: Approved

Holy Cross
515 Alabo St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Wilmot R. & Florine L. Shows, owners.
Housing Unit Demolition Task Force, applicant. RESULT: Begin 30-day layover

401 Andry St./5400 Douglass St.: Review of the ARC recommendations for
conceptual approval for the construction of a single family residence.
Global Green, USA, owner/applicant. John C. Williams, architect;
Workshop/apd, LLC, architect. RESULT: Approved

6212 Burgundy St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Emiel Maxwell, owner. Housing Unit
Demolition Task Force, applicant. RESULT: Removed from the agenda because
applicant submitted request to rescind the voluntary demolition

5130 Chartres St.: Review of staff and ARC recommendations regarding the
reconstruction of an ancillary building and one-story addition to an
existing church.Greater Little Zion Missionary Baptist Church, Owner; Rev.
Gilbert Scie, applicant; Donald S. Richardson, architect. RESULT: Approved

4804 Dauphine St.: Proposal for construction of a one story addition with
side porch. Preservation Resource Center, owner; Aimee Charbonneau,
architect/applicant . RESULT: Approved

4901 Dauphine St.: Request for time to correct work done without a
Certificate of Appropriateness. Doretha P. Jefferson, owner/applicant.
RESULT: Approved (applicant given eight months to correct work)

5609-11 Dauphine St.: Request for the retention of a brown roof installed
without a Certificate of Appropriateness. Joseph A. Oster, Jr.
owner/applicant. RESULT: Denied

5902 Dauphine St: Request for the retention of inappropriate windows
installed without a Certificate of Appropriateness. Carnese M. Williams,
owner/applicant. RESULT: Approved with stipulation that applicant recess the
windows and install wooden window screens

622-24 Deslonde St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING for a parking lot.Paulette
Guerra, owner. Adolph Klundt, applicant. RESULT: Deferred 30 days to allow
applicant to work with neighborhood association on alternatives to
demolition

611 Flood St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Onell & Samuel Johnson, owners.
Housing Unit Demolition Task Force, applicant. RESULT: Begin 30-day layover

821 Jourdan Ave.: Proposal for the construction of a partial porch infill
addition. Ann Schexnyder, owner/applicant RESULT: Deferred 30 days due to
lack of appearance by applicant

4900 Royal St.: Request for the retention of inappropriate windows and an
architectural grade brown roof installed without a Certificate of
Appropriateness. Terrence H. Butler, Sr., owner/applicant. RESULT: Approved
because applicant’s Katrina repair permit did not state it covered only
interior repairs and his intent to install wooden window screens

603 Tricou St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Stanford S. & Jacquelyn N.
Collins, owners. Housing Unit Demolition Task Force, applicant. RESULT:
Begin 30-day layover

Irish Channel
3419 Annunciation St. Demolition by Neglect, Preliminary Citation RESULT:
Approved

3122 Chippewa St. Demolition by Neglect, Preliminary Citation RESULT:
Approved

3033 Chippewa St.: Request for the retention of a rear addition constructed
without a Certificate of Appropriateness. Keirsten Williams,
owner/applicant. RESULT: Approved with details to be worked out at staff
level

719-21 Jackson Ave.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING for a parking lot. Sixth
Baptist Church, owner/applicant. RESULT: Begin 30-day layover

922 Ninth St.: Request for the retention of vinyl windows installed without
a Certificate of Appropriateness. Alireza Haratizadeh, owner/applicant.
RESULT: Denied retention of vinyl windows on new addition visible from
public right of way; Approved retention of side window on new addition with
the installation of wooden window screen and windows on original structure
because they are less visible from public right of way

815 Pleasant St. Demolition by Neglect, Preliminary Citation RESULT:
Approved

800 Washington Ave.: Review and appeal of the ARC recommendations regarding
the renovation of an existing two-story commercial building. Deborah Hinson,
owner/applicant. RESULT: Deferred 30 days due to lack of appearance by
applicant

Lower Garden District
1512 Camp St.: Request for the retention of work completed in deviation from
approved drawings. Pat McEvoy, owner; Ray Leach Construction, applicant.
RESULT: Denied

962 Felicity St. Demolition by Neglect, Preliminary Citation RESULT:
Approved
940-42 Race St.: Request for the retention of a brown roof. John Eckert,
owner; Glynn Hyar, applicant. RESULT: Approved because of Katrina roof
repair exemption

1244 Magazine St.: Request for the retention of inappropriately sized
windows installed without a Certificate of Appropriateness. Michael Love,
owner/architect. RESULT: Denied

1707 Religious St.: (outside of district boundaries) Removal of designation
as a landmark. RESULT: Approved

919 St. Andrew St. Request for the retention of a vinyl window on the second
floor of the Constance Street elevation. Hope House Inc., owner/applicant.
RESULT: Denied

St. Charles Avenue
3338 St. Charles Ave.: Review of the ARC recommendations for conceptual
approval for the renovation of an existing commercial building. SCI
Management, owner; Lewis W. Stirling, applicant; Stephanie Ory, architect;
Carl E. Woodward, contractor. RESULT: Approved with details to be worked out
at staff and ARC level

Tremé
1916 Gov. Nicholls St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Walter Berard, Jr., owner.
Housing Unit Demolition Task Force, applicant. RESULT: Begin 30-day layover

1538-40 N. Claiborne Avenue: Request for the retention of inappropriate
windows, door, & security cage. Jacqueline Jones Franklin, owner/applicant.
RESULT: Approved retention of windows; Denied retention of door and security
cage

1018 N. Dorgenois Street: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Mary Andry, owner. Housing
Unit Demolition Task Force, applicant. RESULT: Approved

1463 St. Claude Ave. Demolition by Neglect, Formal Citation RESULT: Approved

1729 St. Philip St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Judith Williams & Peter W.
Dangerfield, owners. Housing Unit Demolition Task Force, applicant. RESULT:
Removed from the agenda because FEMA determined building is not eligible for
a federally funded demolition

2627-29 St. Ann St.: DEMOLITION OF BUILDING Lorraine Bowman, owner. Housing
Unit Demolition Task Force, applicant. RESULT: Begin 30-day layover